Animality, Metaethical Judgments and Predictive Justice by Ekin Erkan




In a wading pool of philosophical mire and superimpositions - square cubes retrofitted upon cylindrical perforations - Anne-Françoise Schmid, “scientist amongst philosophers and philosopher amongst scientists,” rises from the morass, pronouncing that:

[t]he Earth is then silent, and is only perceived by the plants. La Mettrie could have taught us this in L’Homme-Plante. This silence is profound, more profound than the philosopher believes it to be, who thinks to have seamed [couturé] his system - for example, by his exclusion of women and animals. It is the silence which reaches him when, finally, he learns that there are other philosophies as lively as his and that he must postulate the de jure multiplicity of philosophies. Therefore, philosophy is silent: only isolated philosophies are talkative [bavardes]. ... We have the obligation of a silence, but a new silence, which does not result from the absence of noise.

Indeed, it is not a unified theory that Schmid seeks to impose but rather a political and poetic musing, one which recalls Katerina Kolozova’s comments in Capitalism’s Holocaust of Animals (2019) concerning animality as a brute scaffold upon which Capital materiality creates “victims-in-person.” This reduction is the foundational gesture of Capital, diffuse and ripe for exacting surplus out of “pure value” - that is, life-preservation and vestiges of “reason” from divine violence: “[t]he Earth sees us, the animal sees us, the woman sees us. And the planet sees us, too. We believed we were the only ones to see.”

Read more about Animality, Metaethical Judgments and Predictive Justice by Ekin Erkan

Current Issue

Vol 16 No 1-2 (2019): Vol. 16, No. 1-2 (Summer - Winter 2019) - Issue No. 30-31
Vol. 16, No. 1-2 (Summer - Winter 2019) - Issue No. 30-31
  • Publisher: Institute of Social Sciences and Humanities – Skopje
  • Authors: Zdravko Saveski, Andreas Vasileiou, Akis Gavriilidis, Blair Taylor, David Roden, Ekin Erkan, Davor Löffler, John J. McGraw, Niels N. Johannsen, Neda Genova, Ana Blazheva, Alkisti Efthymiou, Athena Athanasiou, Tsvetelina Hristova, Giuseppe Capalbo, Eszter Kováts
  • Language(s): English
  • Publication Date: 2019
  • Page Count: 130
  • Print Run: 200
  • Size: 240X207X30


Price for a print copy: This issue is not for sale and is for free, and you can purchase it by only paying 5 EUR for shippment. Additionally, you can also order this issue for free if you purchase any of the other back issues listed for sale. 
How to order?: To order a copy of any publication from our catalog, please, order directly with the Institute` by way of bank order (wire) which can be done electronically from your home. Please contact us via email for detailed instructions concerning order placement and our banking information.




  • Zdravko Saveski: One in Seven and a Half: Local Activism against the Global Climate Crisis [EN]
  • Andreas Vasileiou: Exploring the Practices of Greek Municipalities with Left-wing Majorities between 2014-2019: The Battle for the Commons and the Limits of Action [EN]
  • Akis Gavriilidis: Billy Wilder as a Critic of Humanitarian Intervention [EN]
  • Refusing the False Choice Between Individual and Collective Liberation: Interview with Blair Taylor [EN] 


  • David Roden: Subtractive-Catastrophic Xenophilia [EN]
  • Ekin Erkan: Laruelle Qua Stiegler: On Non-Marxism and the Transindividual [EN]
  • Davor Löffler, John J. McGraw † and Niels N. Johannsen: Weapons in and as History: On the Ontogenerative Function of Materialized Preemption and Intelligence in Weapons Technology [EN]
  • Neda Genova: Material-semiotic Transformations of the Berlin Wall in Post-Communist Bulgaria [EN]
  • Ana Blazheva: Macedonian Affective Rhizome: Fear and Shame in the Case of the Macedonian “Name Issue” [EN]


  • Alkisti Efthymiou in Conversation with Athena Athanasiou: Spectral Publics and Antifascist Eventualities [EN]


  • Tsvetelina Hristova: Towards Marina Gržinić (Ed.), Border Thinking: Disassembling Histories of Racialized Violence [EN]
  • Giuseppe Capalbo: Towards Karin Sellberg, Lena Wånggren and Kamillea Aghtan (Eds.), Corporeality and Culture: Bodies in Movement [EN]
  • Eszter Kováts: “Not A Thing?” Rogers Brubaker’s Trans: Gender and Race in an Age of Unsettled Identities and Its Relevance for Central and Eastern Europe [EN]


Download the whole issue here.

Published: 2019-12-28
View All Issues

Identities: Journal for Politics, Gender and Culture is an open-access, peer-reviewed international journal that seeks to serve as a platform for the theoretical production of Southeastern Europe and enable its visibility and an opening for international debate with authors from both the “intellectual centers” and the “intellectual margins” of the world. It is particularly interested in promoting theoretical investigations which see issues of politics, gender and culture as inextricably interrelated. It is open to all theoretical strands, to all schools and non-schools of thought without prioritizing any of the canonical Masters of philosophy. It does not seek doctrinal consistency, but it seeks consistency in rigor of investigation which can combine frameworks of interpretation derived from various and sometimes opposed schools of thought. Our passion is one for topics rather than philosophical masters.

Identities is published by the Institute of Social Sciences and Humanities - Skopje, Macedonia.